Elevate your sandwich game with these creative spreads! While classic mayo and mustard have their place, there’s something special about whipping up your own homemade spread.
The result? A lunch that’s anything but monotonous. These versatile toppings can breathe new life into even the most mundane sandwich, adding a burst of flavor and excitement to each bite.
From creamy avocado to rich tuna or decadent chocolate cream, these spreads are designed to amplify your fillings – and some can even stand alone as an appetizer!
Whether you’re in the mood for something vegan-friendly, meaty, or simply indulgent, there’s a spread here to suit every taste and type of sandwich.
Jalapeño Bean Sandwich Spread
This innovative oil-free sandwich spread boasts a dual appeal: its delectable flavor and the added boost of protein it provides. The core ingredients – pinto beans, pickled jalapenos, and corn – are infused with a blend of spices that evoke a distinctly Mexican flair. I’m envisioning this spread as the crowning glory of a seven-layer sandwich, paired with cheese, tomatoes, lettuce, olives, and perhaps even some avocado.
If anyone else is intrigued by the possibility of savoring such a creation, please don’t hesitate to let me know!
Creamy Tuna Spread
While tuna sandwiches are a classic, using a spread can elevate the dish to new heights. The combination of canned tuna with capers, garlic, lemon, dill, shallots, and olive oil creates a delicious mayo-free alternative. For those who enjoy a bit of heat, adding a few dashes of hot sauce takes it up another notch.
Tofu Sandwich Spread
Elevate your sandwich game by experimenting with tofu as a spread, reminiscent of a vegan twist on the classic tuna sandwich. This surprisingly simple combination involves blending baked tofu with vegan mayo and celery. While straightforward, this foundation can be elevated by adding scallions and nutritional yeast for an added depth of flavor.
Carrot and Cheese Spread
Indulge in the flavors of Russia without leaving your kitchen! This versatile cheese spread is a masterclass in incorporating hidden veggies into your daily meals. By blending shredded carrots with two types of cheese, garlic, and mayo, you’ll create a delightful accompaniment to your favorite lunch meats like turkey, pastrami, or even bologna.
Creamy Avocado Sandwich Spread
This avocado spread is a one-of-a-kind creation that seamlessly blends the characteristics of both crema and mayonnaise. Its distinctive profile comes from a combination of ingredients including lemon zest, hard-boiled eggs, cream cheese, fresh dill, and – of course – two ripe avocados. I’m fond of preparing extra batches so I can generously spread it on my morning toast, leaving me with a surplus that easily extends to my sandwiches as well.
Cranberry Mayo Spread
Say hello to a game-changing Thanksgiving turkey sandwich spread! This sweet, tangy, and creamy concoction requires only five ingredients to create a flavor profile that’s sure to elevate your leftovers. And the best part? It’s vegan-friendly, making it perfect for meat-free sandwiches too.
Spicy Hot Pepper Spread
Get ready to ignite your taste buds with this sizzling Italian spread, infused with the fiery essence of Calabrian peppers. While chili peppers take center stage, a medley of other ingredients like eggplant, mushrooms, bell peppers, garlic, and savory seasonings add depth and complexity to the mix. This bold and spicy condiment is begging to be paired with a meaty, cheesy sandwich that can stand up to its fiery personality.
Think towering stacks of sliced meats and melted cheeses – the perfect accompaniment to this devilishly delicious spread.
Garlic, Tomato, & Herb Sandwich Spread
This delectable aioli is an elevated version of traditional mayonnaise, boasting a rich flavor profile that will elevate your sandwiches to new heights. While it’s understandable to opt for the simplicity of mayo, this four-ingredient spread is surprisingly quick to prepare, requiring only 5 minutes of your time.
The result is well worth the minimal effort, as it adds depth and complexity to a variety of sandwich options, such as a satisfying muffuletta or Italian sub – both of which are equally impressive when paired with this flavorful spread.
Chocolate Cream Spread
While chocolate and sandwiches may not be a traditional pairing, they surprisingly work well together. Think of it as peanut butter’s alternative to jelly, but with an indulgent twist.
The combination of dark chocolate and unsweetened cocoa with milk and condensed milk is the key to this unique match. For an added layer of sweetness, try pairing it with Nutella and sliced bananas for a tasty treat.
To take it to the next level, swap out regular bread for cinnamon sugar toast.
Either way, kids will love the sweet and indulgent combination.
Artichoke Tapenade
One vegan artichoke recipe that’s incredibly easy to incorporate into your daily diet is this bold and savory spread. Not only does it make for an excellent party dip, but it also shines as a sandwich spread. Try pairing it with roasted veggies on a plant-based sandwich for a satisfying meal. For added creaminess, you can even add thick slices of fresh mozzarella if dairy is part of your diet – a game-changing twist that elevates the flavors to new heights.
Homemade Pesto
Pesto’s vibrant flavor profile is characterized by its bold herbal notes and a generous amount of pungent garlic. The best part? It’s incredibly simple to prepare at home. This budget-conscious recipe cleverly combines pine nuts and walnuts, providing an affordable alternative to traditional pesto recipes. For an added layer of creaminess, you can also blend it with soft cream cheese.
Imagine the delightful surprise when you spread this flavorful mixture on your next grilled cheese sandwich – pure bliss!
Salmon Sandwich Spread
Indulge in the delightful fusion of flavors as you savor this salmon spread, boasting a harmonious balance of savory, lemony, and slightly spicy notes. The convenience of using canned salmon means no cooking is required, making it an effortless addition to your daily routine. Moreover, this spread serves as a rich source of protein and Omega-3 fatty acids, both essential components for maintaining overall well-being.
To reap the benefits, simply spread it on sourdough bread for a delectable open-faced sandwich. For added texture and visual appeal, consider topping with arugula and tomato slices, elevating this humble snack to new heights.
Ground Bologna Spread with Pickles & Onions
While some may be skeptical about the allure of bologna, its unique blend of creamy, savory, briny, and oniony flavors is undeniably captivating. Hailing from the Midwest, this beloved spread has the power to win over even the most hesitant palates. With a single taste, you’ll discover why it’s become a treasured staple in many households. So, if you’re ready to have your mind changed about bologna, take the first step by trying out our recipe – we dare you not to fall under its charms!
Mayo Egg Sandwich Spread
The humble egg salad sandwich has a secret life – it’s just as delicious when served as a spread. The standard ingredients of hard-boiled eggs, creamy mayo, and tangy mustard provide a solid foundation. What elevates this classic to new heights are the unexpected additions of pickled gherkins, their juice, and sweet pepper. This unique combination is even more exciting when piled high on crusty bread with fresh parsley and savory lunch meat.
Alternatively, you can simply enjoy it as is, allowing the flavors to meld together in perfect harmony. For a more refined experience, consider smearing it onto crispy crostini for a satisfying appetizer. And with that, the egg salad sandwich’s versatility is revealed.
Tomato and Basil Spread
If you’ve got a can of tomato paste hiding in the back of your pantry, now’s the perfect opportunity to dig it out and unleash its bold flavors. This Italian-inspired spread is all about showcasing the rich, tomato-forward taste, with hints of garlic, fresh basil, and Greek yogurt adding depth and complexity. One of my favorite ways to enjoy this tasty condiment is by elevating a humble lunch meat sandwich into something truly special.
But I’m also convinced it would be absolutely sensational as a topping for a grilled cheese – the creamy cheese and crunchy bread providing the perfect foil for the tangy, tomatoey goodness.
Cucumber Sandwich Spread
There’s something about a classic cream cheese sandwich that just can’t be beat. But I’d argue that adding cucumber spread takes it to a whole new level. The refreshing combination of cooling cucumber and tangy dill creates the ultimate fresh spread. And when you add the richness of cream cheese and the subtle tang of mayo, you’ve got a flavor profile that’s simply unbeatable.
It’s not just limited to lunchtime, either – I think this same spread would be incredible on a breakfast bagel sandwich with smoked salmon, ripe tomato, and salty capers. The possibilities are endless!
Southern Pimento Cheese
Pimento cheese, a beloved Southern staple, transcends its simplicity as a dip. In my opinion, its true essence shines when paired with bread, elevating the humble sandwich game. Whether you choose to stack it between two slices or use it as the star of a grilled cheese extravaganza, this flavorful spread is sure to delight. But wait, there’s more!
When combined with the classic BLT, pimento cheese adds an unexpected layer of complexity, transforming the quintessential combo into a truly memorable culinary experience.