Beat the heat with these refreshing and creamy icebox pie recipes perfect for BBQs and gatherings. Sweet, light, and indulgent, they’re sure to please even the most discerning palates. While some may argue that true icebox pies are no-bake, including crust and all, others believe it’s about keeping them chilled until serving time. I fall into the latter camp, which is why this curated list of icebox pie recipes features a mix of both no-bake and baked elements.
And for the record, an ‘icebox’ simply refers to what we now call the fridge!
Chocolate Icebox Pie
Indulge in a silky-smooth chocolate icebox pie that’s nothing short of phenomenal. The pièce de résistance? A simple crust-baking process – or skip it altogether with a pre-made crust. The rest is a breeze: just mix, stir, and chill. You’ll have this decadent delight ready in under 40 minutes, minus the refrigeration time.
Lemon Icebox Pie with Marshmallow Meringue
Indulge in a refreshing twist with this lemon icebox pie, topped off with an airy marshmallow meringue that’s simply divine! While it may not be a no-bake affair, the end result is well worth the minor extra effort required. For starters, you’ll need to bake the cracker crust and let the filling set in the oven. The payoff, however, is a delightfully tangy and sweet treat that’s sure to satisfy your cravings.
And don’t even get me started on the marshmallow meringue – its light-as-air texture and subtle sweetness are truly genius. Plus, it holds up beautifully in the fridge, without weeping or becoming soggy.
Blackberry Icebox Pie
Imagine savoring every bite of silky and luscious pies without a single word wasted on their descriptions. To get us there, let’s dive into the delectable world of blackberry icebox pie! Not only does it boast a stunning purple hue, but its bold blackberry flavor is nothing short of extraordinary. While preparation requires a bit more effort, trust that the payoff will be well worth your while.
If you’re seeking the quintessential summer dessert to impress and delight, look no further than this show-stopping blackberry icebox pie.
Strawberry Icebox Pie with Condensed Milk
For those who have a sweet tooth for strawberries, this lovely pink pie is a must-try. Made with real strawberries, it’s a delightful treat that’s surprisingly easy to prepare. Start by using a pre-made crust, which will save you nearly an hour of prep time. Just be sure to plan ahead and give the pie a couple of hours in the freezer before serving – it’s worth the wait!
Blueberry Icebox Pie
Indulge in the sweet indulgence of our show-stopping blueberry icebox pie, a culinary masterpiece that’s as effortless as it is delicious. This refreshing treat can be yours in just over 30 minutes, boasting a vibrant, creamy texture and an explosion of juicy blueberries that will leave you craving more.
Millionaire Pie
Indulge in a slice of sunshine with this fruity pie that’s as vibrant as its name suggests! The rich and creamy filling, crafted from a trifecta of cream cheese, condensed milk, and lemon juice, offers a delightful balance of flavors. With crushed pineapple, chopped cherries, and crunchy pecans adding natural sweetness and texture, every bite is a masterclass in contrasts. The finishing touch? A sprinkle of mandarin segments that add a burst of citrus freshness to each morsel.
It’s a tropical getaway in every deliciously scrummy spoonful.
Easy Icebox Coconut Cream Pie
While many pies boast a tangy tartness, this coconut cream pie is a sweet and tropical departure from the norm. The combination of coconut pudding and flakes in every bite creates a truly indulgent experience. For an added layer of coconutiness, consider topping it with whipped coconut cream instead of traditional heavy cream. This subtle tweak can elevate the flavor to new heights.
Black Bottom Peanut Butter Icebox Pie
While this icebox pie retains its signature silky texture, the addition of ganache, Graham Cracker crust, and peanut butter imbues it with a unique character. The crunch from these elements provides a pleasant contrast in texture, while the peanut butter’s thickness and richness significantly depart from the airy quality found in other options.
This indulgent treat is unequivocally super sweet and ultra-rich, yet its unapologetic decadence is precisely what makes it so irresistible to fans of peanut butter and chocolate.
Oreo Icebox Pie
This Oreo icebox pie is a must-have dessert that requires just six ingredients and approximately 30 minutes of preparation time. The marshmallow filling is delightfully sweet and surprisingly easy to prepare, complementing the crunchy Oreo crust beautifully. To add an extra layer of fun, you can easily customize this recipe by substituting different flavored Oreos, such as golden, mint, or strawberry cheesecake varieties.
This versatility makes it a great option for catering to diverse tastes or experimenting with new flavor combinations.
Icebox Cherry Pie
One of the most striking aspects of this icebox pie is its imposing stature, which belies a rich tapestry of flavors. By stacking three tiers of creamy cheesecake, four layers of crunchy vanilla wafers, and two layers of luscious cherry filling, the pie’s designer has created a true masterpiece. The crowning glory? A dollop of whipped cream infused with the sweetness of cheesecake. It’s little wonder that this showstopper is affectionately known as the ‘mile-high’ pie.
Despite its grandiose appearance, every layer is bursting with flavor, making it an irresistible treat.
No Bake Strawberry Pie with Cream Cheese Filling
The timeless combination of strawberries and cheesecake takes center stage in this decadent no-bake pie. Rich cream cheese filling and an abundance of fresh fruit – a whopping three pounds! – make it a must-try dessert. A classic Graham Cracker crust provides the perfect base for this sweet treat. When preparing, be sure to plan ahead; the strawberry sauce or jello requires at least eight hours in the refrigerator, ideally overnight, to allow the flavors to meld together.
Raspberry Lemonade Icebox Pie
Ditch the ordinary lemonade pie and elevate it by incorporating juicy raspberries into your mix. The combination of whipped cream, vanilla, condensed milk, and thawed raspberry lemonade concentrate creates a delightful balance of sweet and tangy flavors. While the recipe doesn’t explicitly call for fresh raspberries, I highly recommend folding them into the filling to give this dessert an extra layer of complexity and visual appeal.
Strawberry Margarita Icebox Pie
The strawberry margarita pie is a true showstopper, with its layered strawberry and lime garnish resembling a masterpiece more than a dessert! The combination of flavors is equally impressive, boasting a bright and tangy taste tempered by the bold sweetness of the strawberries. To add a touch of sophistication, the crust is topped with a crunchy pretzel crumb, providing a delightful textural contrast to the creamy filling.
I’m confident that anyone who tries this pie will be hooked and eagerly seeking seconds!
Banana Pudding Icebox Pie
The aroma of this pie is reminiscent of Gwen Stefani’s iconic song ‘Bananas.’ And it’s easy to see why – every bite explodes with the unmistakable flavor and essence of ripe bananas! While its namesake, banana pudding, may not be the most visually appealing dessert, this pie’s presentation more than makes up for it. For anyone who shares my passion for all things banana, this is a must-try treat that you won’t want to share – or stop at just one slice.
No-Bake Butterscotch Pie
Indulge in the sweet and satisfying taste of this butterscotch pie, requiring only a few simple ingredients. It’s the perfect dessert for gatherings and celebrations, offering a delightful balance between flavors. Unlike other desserts that may be too tart or fruity, this one is richly infused with brown sugar, caramel notes, and a touch of buttery nuts. The result is a truly scrumptious treat that will leave everyone wanting more.
Lime Icebox Pie
While lemon icebox pie may be the most iconic of these desserts, I highly recommend giving lime icebox pie a try! This lesser-known treat is just as scrumptious and boasts a refreshing, tangy flavor profile that’s perfect for warm weather. The best part? It requires zero baking time, making it an effortless option to prepare at home. A combination of gelatin, cream cheese, lime juice, and other ingredients yields a delightful texture that simply melts in your mouth.
Whether you’re looking for a show-stopping dessert for a summer gathering or a quick treat to satisfy your sweet tooth, this no-bake delight is sure to please.
Orange Creamsicle Icebox Pie
If citrus isn’t your thing, I’ve got a delightful orange pie recipe that’s sure to delight. It captures the essence of an orange creamsicle in a pie form, perfectly balancing sweet, tangy, and citrusy flavors. No need for popsicles when you can savor this scrumptious treat instead? Head to the Recipe page to get started.
